Benjamin Moore Paint Stores in Brooklyn, Queens & The Bronx

Sherwin-Williams Pewter Green vs Benjamin Moore Vintage Vogue

Pewter Green and Vintage Vogue

Deep green paint colors continue to dominate cabinetry, built-ins, and exteriors. Both are rich, earthy greens — but their undertones and depth create noticeable differences once they’re on the wall.

Let’s break it down.

Overall Paint Color Tone

Sherwin-Williams Pewter Green (SW 6208)

  • Dark green with gray influence
  • Muted and slightly cool
  • Modern, organic feel
  • Pewter Green feels softer and more subdued.

Benjamin Moore Vintage Vogue (462)

  • Deep forest green
  • Stronger green presence
  • Slightly richer and more saturated
  • Vintage Vogue feels deeper and more dramatic.

Color Undertones: Where They Differ

Sherwin-Williams Pewter Green Undertones:

  • Noticeable gray base
  • Slight blue-green influence
  • Can look moodier in low light
  • If you want a softened, muted green → Pewter Green.

Benjamin Moore Vintage Vogue Undertones:

  • Stronger green core
  • Subtle blackened depth
  • Less gray than Pewter Green
  • If you want bold, classic deep green → Vintage Vogue.

Paint Color LRV (Light Reflectance Value)

Both are dark colors that absorb a lot of light. Because Pewter Green has more gray, it may appear slightly lighter in bright rooms. Vintage Vogue tends to look richer and heavier.

  • Sherwin-Williams Pewter Green LRV: ~12
  • Benjamin Moore Vintage Vogue LRV: ~11

How The Colors Look in Different Lighting

Sunlight and the lights in your home have a strong impact how a paint color looks at different times of the day. Get a FREE paint sample here and see how a color looks before buying!

Bright Natural Light

  • Pewter Green shows more gray and subtle blue undertones
  • Vintage Vogue looks more vibrantly green

Low Light / Evening

  • Pewter Green can feel smoky and modern
  • Vintage Vogue becomes deep and dramatic

Exterior Sunlight

  • Pewter Green appears softer and slightly muted
  • Vintage Vogue looks bold and stately

Best Uses for Each

Pewter Green Works Beautifully For:

  • Kitchen cabinetry
  • Built-ins
  • Accent walls
  • Modern farmhouse exteriors
  • Bathrooms

Pairs well with: warm whites, brass fixtures, light wood tones

Vintage Vogue Works Beautifully For:

  • Dining rooms
  • Moody offices
  • Library-style spaces
  • Front doors
  • Traditional exteriors

Pairs well with: crisp white trim, gold hardware, dark wood

Which One Feels More Modern?

  • Pewter Green leans more modern because of its gray influence. If you’re going for a soft, organic, contemporary look → Pewter Green.
  • Vintage Vogue feels more traditional and classic. If you want bold, timeless drama → Vintage Vogue.

Which Color Should You Choose?

Choose Sherwin-Williams Pewter Green if:

  • You prefer muted tones
  • You want flexibility with décor
  • You like cooler undertones

Choose Benjamin Moore Vintage Vogue if:

  • You want a stronger green statement
  • You love deep, saturated color
  • You’re designing a more traditional space

What This Means for Your Home

Both colors are excellent choices for homeowners wanting to move beyond gray while still keeping things sophisticated. Remember to always sample any paint color in your specific lighting situation and compare against your flooring, countertops, and trim before committing.

Visit one of our paint stores near you to speak with our well-trained team members.