Sherwin-Williams Agreeable Gray SW 7029 and Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray HC-173 are two warm, versatile neutrals that sit in the territory between gray and beige. Both can provide a softer, warmer alternative to a traditional gray, but there are noticeable differences between the two.
And if you’ve been searching for Benjamin Moore Agreeable Gray, there’s an important distinction: Agreeable Gray is a Sherwin-Williams color, not a Benjamin Moore color. Edgecomb Gray is one Benjamin Moore color worth considering if you like the general look of Agreeable Gray.
What Color is Sherwin-Williams Agreeable Gray?
Agreeable Gray SW 7029 is a warm gray with a beige undertone. Sherwin-Williams lists it as a neutral and gives it a Light Reflectance Value, or LRV, of 60.386.
That combination gives Agreeable Gray its popular greige appearance. It has enough warmth to keep it from looking like a cool, stark gray, while still retaining a noticeable gray influence.
Like most neutrals, its appearance can shift depending on the lighting, surrounding colors, flooring, furniture, and other finishes in the room.
What Color is Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray?
Edgecomb Gray HC-173 is a warm Benjamin Moore neutral from the Historical Colors collection. Benjamin Moore describes it as a warm and welcoming neutral and identifies Edgecomb Gray as a warm gray with brown undertones.
It has an LRV of 63.09, making it a relatively light neutral. Its warmth can cause it to appear more beige in some settings, while its gray side can become more noticeable in others.
Edgecomb Gray is also known as Baby Fawn OC-15.
Agreeable Gray vs. Edgecomb Gray: What’s the Difference?
The biggest differences between Agreeable Gray and Edgecomb Gray come down to their undertones and relative lightness.
| Agreeable Gray SW 7029 | Edgecomb Gray HC-173 | |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Sherwin-Williams | Benjamin Moore |
| Color Family | Neutral / Warm Gray | Neutral / Warm Gray |
| Undertones | Beige | Brown |
| LRV | 60.386 | 63.09 |
| Overall Appearance | Warm gray/greige | Warm gray/beige |
Edgecomb Gray has the higher LRV, so it reflects slightly more light than Agreeable Gray. The difference isn’t dramatic, but Edgecomb Gray can appear a little lighter.
The undertones also distinguish them. Agreeable Gray’s beige undertone provides its warmth, while Edgecomb Gray has a brown undertone that can give it a somewhat earthier appearance.
Which is Lighter: Agreeable Gray or Edgecomb Gray?
Edgecomb Gray is slightly lighter than Agreeable Gray. Edgecomb Gray has an LRV of 63.09 compared with 60.386 for Agreeable Gray. Because the numbers are fairly close, these colors occupy a similar range of depth, but Edgecomb Gray reflects somewhat more light.
Keep in mind that LRV doesn’t tell you exactly how two colors will look next to each other. Undertones and lighting can make colors with similar LRVs appear considerably different.
Which is Warmer: Agreeable Gray or Edgecomb Gray?
Both colors are warm neutrals, so neither should be treated as a traditional cool gray.
Agreeable Gray gets its warmth from a beige undertone, while Edgecomb Gray has brown undertones. Depending on the room, Edgecomb Gray can sometimes read more beige or earthy, while Agreeable Gray can retain more of a gray appearance.
Because surrounding finishes can emphasize different undertones, it’s worth sampling both if you’re deciding between them.
Where Do Agreeable Gray and Edgecomb Gray Work Best?
Both colors are versatile enough to be considered for large areas of a home, including:
- Living rooms
- Bedrooms
- Hallways
- Dining rooms
- Kitchens
- Open-concept spaces
The better choice depends less on the type of room and more on the lighting and the permanent finishes surrounding the paint.
If your flooring, stone, countertops, or furniture have warmer earthy tones, Edgecomb Gray may fit naturally into the palette. If you’re looking for a warm neutral that maintains a little more gray, Agreeable Gray may be worth considering.
Is Edgecomb Gray the Benjamin Moore Equivalent of Agreeable Gray?
Edgecomb Gray is a good Benjamin Moore alternative to consider, but remember, it isn’t an exact equivalent of Agreeable Gray.
Paint colors from different manufacturers shouldn’t be assumed to be interchangeable simply because they have similar LRVs or occupy the same general color family. Agreeable Gray and Edgecomb Gray have different formulations and undertones, and they can look noticeably different once they’re on the wall.
If you like Agreeable Gray but prefer Benjamin Moore paint, Edgecomb Gray is a logical place to start when comparing colors.
Agreeable Gray or Edgecomb Gray: Which Should You Choose?
Choose Agreeable Gray if you prefer its balance of gray and beige and want the specific appearance of Sherwin-Williams SW 7029.
Choose Edgecomb Gray if you want a slightly lighter Benjamin Moore neutral with warm brown undertones and a tendency to move between gray and beige depending on its surroundings.
Neither is universally better. The best choice will depend on the other colors and materials in your room.
Compare Edgecomb Gray at Loconsolo Paints
If you’re considering Edgecomb Gray or looking for a Benjamin Moore alternative to Agreeable Gray, stop by Loconsolo Paints. Our knowledgeable team can help you compare Benjamin Moore neutrals, understand their undertones, and choose samples to see how the colors look in your space.
Visit one of our NYC paint store locations to explore Edgecomb Gray and other Benjamin Moore warm neutrals.